Skip to content

Brought to you by

Dentons logo

US Tax Disputes

Keeping an eye on US tax controversy and litigation developments.

open menu close menu

US Tax Disputes

  • Home
  • About us
  • State and Local (Subnational) Taxation

Green Rock Rolls Over Notice 2017-10

By Michelle Levin, Ronald Levitt, and Sarah Green
February 13, 2023
  • General
  • IRS
Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share via email Share on LinkedIn

In a recently issued memorandum opinion, U.S. District Judge Annemarie Carney Axon dealt the IRS another blow in its ongoing battle over the validity of its syndicated conservation easement listing notice, Notice 2017–10.  The Northern District of Alabama judge sided with Green Rock, LLC in its suit against the IRS asking the court to set aside Notice 2017–10 as an invalid agency action under the Administrative Procedure Act (“APA”).

In December 2016, the IRS issued Notice 2017-10, requiring taxpayers and advisors who participated in certain syndicated conservation easements to report their role in the transaction or face substantial civil, and potentially criminal, penalties.  As was its practice at the time, the IRS issued the listing notice without seeking comment from the general public based on its view that the relevant law allowed the IRS to operate outside the requirements of the APA.    

Green Rock, LLC challenged this action, arguing it was improper for the IRS to impose onerous reporting requirements on taxpayers and their advisors without first seeking comments from the general public as required by the APA.  Not only was the cost of compliance with the listing notice hefty, but the penalties for non-compliance were steep.  Green Rock’s position was supported by a recent Sixth Circuit decision in Mann Construction, setting aside a different listing notice, and the Tax Court’s November 9, 2022, decision in Green Valley Investors, which also set aside Notice 2017-10 for failing to comply with the APA. 

The district court in Green Rock LLC v. IRS agreed with the Sixth Circuit and Tax Court, holding that language in the Treasury Regulation that allows the IRS to identify listed transactions through “listing notices” “does not irreconcilably conflict with the Administrative Procedure Act’s notice-and-comment requirement.” Green Valley Invs., LLC, 159 T.C. at 26, 32 (Pugh, J., concurring); id. at 34 (Toro, J., concurring).  Because the statute did not expressly exempt the listing notice process from the APA’s requirements, the court held that listing notices, like other IRS rules, are subject to the APA. And because the IRS failed to comply with the APA, Notice 2017-10 was invalid. 

The district court then grappled with the implications of its decision that Notice 2017-10 was set aside.  The Tax Court had already held that its decision to set aside Notice 2017-10 applied to “all similarly situated taxpayers who come before us” Green Valley at 23 n.22.  Conversely, a U.S. District Court in Ohio held that its decision setting aside Notice 2017-10 applied only to the plaintiff in that case.  GBX Associates LLC v. United States, No. 1:22-cv-00401 (N.D. Ohio 2022).  Judge Axon concluded that her decision setting aside Notice 2017-10 was not a nationwide injunction based on Supreme Court precedent holding “that an order vacating an agency action is not the same as an injunction.”  So, while the Green Rock decision does not enjoin the IRS from a particular course of conduct, it is still an open question whether the IRS is permitted to take action (such as imposing penalties) for failing to comply with Notice 2017-10, which has been “set aside.”  We expect to see further developments on this question in the coming weeks and months.

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share via email Share on LinkedIn
Subscribe and stay updated
Receive our latest blog posts by email.
Stay in Touch
Michelle Levin

About Michelle Levin

Michelle Abroms Levin is a shareholder in Dentons Sirote’s Huntsville, Alabama office, where she is a member of the Tax practice group.

All posts Full bio

Ronald Levitt

About Ronald Levitt

Ronald Levitt is a shareholder in Dentons Sirote’s Birmingham, Alabama office, where he is a member of the Tax practice group and leads the Dentons Sirote Conservation Easement team. His practice focuses on federal and state controversy matters, including planning and defending conservation easements.

All posts Full bio

Sarah Green

About Sarah Green

Sarah Green is a Managing Associate in Dentons Sirote’s Huntsville, Alabama office. She is a member of the Tax practice group. Her practice focuses on Tax Controversy and Litigation.

All posts Full bio

RELATED POSTS

  • General
  • IRS

11th Circuit Decision – Penalty Approval by Supervisor Allowed at Any Time Prior to Assessment

By Gregory Rhodes, Logan Abernathy, and Emily Ellis
  • FATCA
  • Foreign Tax Credits
  • IRS
  • IRS Administration
  • IRS Examination Process
  • LB&I

IRS Announces Five New Campaigns

By Jeff Erney
  • IRS
  • IRS Administration
  • Litigation
  • Tax Crimes

Supreme Court Agrees to Review Sweeping Tax Obstruction of Justice Decision

By Jeff Erney

About Dentons

Dentons is designed to be different. As the world’s largest law firm with 20,000 professionals in over 200 locations in more than 80 countries, we can help you grow, protect, operate and finance your business. Our polycentric and purpose-driven approach, together with our commitment to inclusion, diversity, equity and ESG, ensures we challenge the status quo to stay focused on what matters most to you. www.dentons.com

Dentons boilerplate image

Twitter

Categories

Additional resources

Visit our Global tax guide to doing business in... 2022.

global tax guide 2022
Dentons logo

© 2023 Dentons

  • Legal notices
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms of use
  • Cookies on this site